7.5 makes no sense...

User Rating: 9 | Makai Senki Disgaea 3 PS3
I agree with the writers opinion until they knock it for the graphics. I have purchased all of N1's games since I got my hands on Disgaea. Part of the charm of the series is its sprite based graphics, especially Disgaea. It wouldn't feel like an N1 game if it were fully 3D, however, I wouldn't mind another game from them in 3D. Even if you do take into account the graphics and the camera (which is bad, not horrible) and take off the 2.5, it is ludicrous.
I read in another article that talked to the designer of the game, why it was not for the PS2 and he mentioned that it allowed them a lot more room to make larger levels for the game and allowed for more voice acting (which they failed to mention the fact that there is a whole lot more dialogue). Not to mention the ability for downloadable content.
If your only problem with a game is the graphics but everything else is outstanding you are not making a strong case for yourself. Cosnidering the graphics aren't even terrible, the score given does not make a whole lot of sense.
I bet they won't mark down Chrono Trigger for the DS when that isn't updated with full 3D, which we know is entirely plausible since they have been doing it with the Final Fantasy series...or at least CG cut scenes...