I don’t want to say it’s bad… but I can’t say it’s good

User Rating: 4 | The Evil Within PC

Pros:

  • Animations
  • Graphics
  • Gore
  • Really weird
  • Unique, disgusting monsters
  • Some unique concepts in the narrative (although they were never fleshed out as much as I wanted them to be)
  • Physics

Cons:

  • Clunky movement
  • Doors open either really super slow or way too loud
  • Inventory system
    • Removes syringes from favorites when they run out
    • Awkward to pause and navigate
  • Some less than thrilling (and really tough) boss battles
    • (I’m thinking specifically of the goofy ass dog thing)
  • Some really freaking hard chapters (in a bad way)
    • (Chapter 6 in particular almost made me give up on the game. Even after lowering the difficulty, there were still tough areas.)
  • Too many instant death traps
    • (This would have been fine if there was a quicksave feature, but with the checkpoint/save system, it got really annoying)
  • Protagonist is really bland
  • Story feels like an afterthought. It seems like it is only there to allow for any creepy environment/monster imaginable, but this sort of took away the game’s heart

Rating:

  • Story *** 3/10
  • Gameplay **** 4/10
  • Atmosphere ****** 6/10
  • Overall **** 4/10

----------------------------------------------------------