SMG Galaxy will get a 10 on GS

And that's just something you have to deal with.

Not since the undeserving TH PS3 will a game get a 10. Galaxy will here.

Those that have played it will back me up.

Yeah right. :roll:

Yeah right. :roll:

K4ss3r

OK.

Maybe, go play the best platforming game ever made and get back to me.

If you haven't already, make a bet. A BIG one that says you'll leave GS if it doesn't get 10 :DKritical_Strike

I already tried in that official thread. They said they wouldn'e take it because I was "too new" or something.

Whatever, I'll still be right in the end.

I've played it. It is, quite simply, the best platformer ever created.

I have good tastes too. Trust me or not, it doesn't matter. I'm going to bed now.

I'd love to believe that, but this is GameSpot we're talkin' about here... and it's a Wii game we're talkin' about.elektrixxx

Doesn't matter.

It redefines the platforming genre, plain and simple. It is better than any game to come before it in its genre.

If this game isn't a 10, nothing is.

It will probably get an 8.0 for reasons like "mario hasn't got voice acting" and "it's not Halo 3".Lilac_Benjie

Imagine the uproar if it actually listed "cons: Not Halo 3" lol

Na it looks like a really awesome game but 9.5 max, I don't think it will get a 10.

It'll get a 9.0 or 9.5, not a 10PS360Fanboy

if it was on 360 you mean?

It will probably get an 8.0 for reasons like "mario hasn't got voice acting" and "it's not Halo 3".Lilac_Benjie

OMG that'd be hilarious, it won't happen. But if it did, WOW.... Gamespots credibility (whats left of it anyway) would be completely GONE! But it'd still be funny. the person who would write something like that, would never work in the gaming news industry again.

8.5

Believe

I'd love to believe that, but this is GameSpot we're talkin' about here... and it's a Wii game we're talkin' about.elektrixxx

Too true. I can't see GS awarding any Wii game with a 10, and they've never given any Mario games that score in the entire history of their existence. So I'd be incredibly surprised if Galaxy gets it.

no 10´s for Wii games , and i think SMG will be a 9.5 Wii`s GOTY and... sheeps will not have anything more to play in years xD

Super Mario Galaxy Galaxy? Is that like an expansion pack or something?

Just kidding. 8.5-9.5

How much common sense can a person lack when they come in here hailing a game as the greatest thing ever in it's genre before they've even played the game from front to back?

Truth is you don't know how great the game is and are on no grounds to claim with 100% confidence it will score a perfect 10 here at Gamespot.

How much common sense can a person lack when they come in here hailing a game as the greatest thing ever in it's genre before they've even played the game from front to back?

Truth is you don't know how great the game is and are on no grounds to claim with 100% confidence it will score a perfect 10 here at Gamespot.

-Despacio-

STOP IT, just STOP IT, how DARE you add common sense to discussion about a storied nintendo franchise started by a Nintendo fanboy, how dare you

and it won't get a 10, graphics will be its downfall, it doesn't look as good as anything on 360 or PS3, even the Burger King games look better

Even if it got 20.0 from Gamespot and every other site, and even if someone gave me 100 bucks i still would not play SMG. That game is so last gen. Graphics, sound....it has annoying controls in some levels(look 1UP video preview), story is most likely some pointless goofy crap. Mario needs rhinoplasty to remove that tumor he has in his nose, now seriously that look was cute 10 years ago, now it is just "WTF ugly"Vojkan80001

Ok what? OIf course if someone gave you a hundred bucks I bet you'd play with traffic (which btw can I suggest?) Where do you get the idea it's last gen? Also coming from someone who is still on last gen, how can you compare it too current? Pointless goofy crap? You clearly don't understand the messages behind any Mario game whatsoever, and tumor he has in his nose.....Whoa nice insult right there, especially to a computer game chararcter, that's real big.

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/action/supermario64/index.html?tag=result;title;1

Looking at the above rating a 9.5 or even 9.0may not even happen.No matter how good galaxy is, Ijust don't think wewill see the impact of another Mario 64 anytime soon. But heyother factors may go into how the review turns out,factorslike the reviewer for example, wich as an individual itmay justfind galaxy as the best thing ever... or not...

And that's just something you have to deal with.

Not since the undeserving TH PS3 will a game get a 10. Galaxy will here.

Those that have played it will back me up.

KingOfKonging

doubtful. nothing will be a lock for 10.

no 10´s for Wii games , and i think SMG will be a 9.5 Wii`s GOTY and... sheeps will not have anything more to play in years xD

hey sheeps , i am playing Eternal Sonata , The Darkness , i finished bioshock and this month i get Mass effect and Asassin`s creed , and i still have in my waiting list HALO 3 , VF5 and some other games.... i think i am happy :D , what does it feel to live expecting just one game in like 5 or 6 months?Yuri_Volte

Har har Fission Mailed.
I bought 3 games in october and will buy another 2 (maybe 3) this month.
Currently Playing Metroid Prime 3 as my single player.
Mario Strikers with friends.
Super Paper Mario after MP3 is finnished.
Then I will buy SMG and finnish it and immediatly buy Zack & Wiki.
After Zack & Wiki I will buy MOH:H2 with 32 people online.
And then maybe but very maybe I will buy NiGHTS.

And then I didnt even begin about 2008.
And we're sheep not sheeps.

No, considering Super Mario 64 redefined platformers and it only got a 9.4. Going from 2D to 3D was a big step, I don't see anything in Galaxy that revolutionary as going from 2D to 3D in platformers.

Galaxy will probably get a 9 but don't even think about it getting a 10.

No, considering Super Mario 64 redefined platformers and it only got a 9.4. Going from 2D to 3D was a big step, I don't see anything in Galaxy that revolutionary as going from 2D to 3D in platformers.

Galaxy will probably get a 9 but don't even think about it getting a 10.

Shadow2k6

[QUOTE="K4ss3r"]

Yeah right. :roll:

KingOfKonging

OK.

Maybe, go play the best platforming game ever made and get back to me.

I can believe it is the best ever made, and it's certainly likely that GS will give it AAA, but AAAA would be a little optimistic.

I can believe it is the best ever made, and it's certainly likely that GS will give it AAA, but AAAA would be a little optimistic.Tylendal

I thought the score for Halo 3 was optimistic. Heck, WarioWare: Smooth moves is a better example.

I don't know what to expect from GS now and I hope no one else is putting their guts on hold (Like me) on their opinion of it. :x

[QUOTE="Tylendal"]I can believe it is the best ever made, and it's certainly likely that GS will give it AAA, but AAAA would be a little optimistic.Teh_Stevz

I thought the score for Halo 3 was optimistic. Heck, WarioWare: Smooth moves is a better example.

I don't know what to expect from GS now and I hope no one else is putting their guts on hold (Like me) on their opinion of it. :x

I don't listen to Gamespot scores anymore. I still read their reviews, but for numbers, I use averages.

TC, need I remind you of this:

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=25855149

[QUOTE="K4ss3r"]

Yeah right. :roll:

KingOfKonging

OK.

Maybe, go play the best platforming game ever made and get back to me.

You mean Banjo?

Even that didn't get a 10

No. That is just ridiculous. Gamespot isn't handing out 10s anymore anyway.DrinkDuff

especially a none xbox360 game lol.

It will be lucky to get a 9.0 here since Mario isn't brutally raping the princess while beating her to death and verbally degrading her at gunpoint in 720P. :Pbcrich959

You forgot the chainsaw.

[QUOTE="bcrich959"]It will be lucky to get a 9.0 here since Mario isn't brutally raping the princess while beating her to death and verbally degrading her at gunpoint in 720P. :Pkort-nilsen

You forgot the chainsaw.

I thought about putting
"Brutally raping her with a chainsaw" but I figured that was just a little too much.Well Mario could be holding her at gunpoint with one of those chainsaw guns from Gears.:lol:

[QUOTE="elektrixxx"]I'd love to believe that, but this is GameSpot we're talkin' about here... and it's a Wii game we're talkin' about.KingOfKonging

Doesn't matter.

It redefines the platforming genre, plain and simple. It is better than any game to come before it in its genre.

If this game isn't a 10, nothing is.

Same could be said about World in Conflict and you didn't see it getting a 10 do you?

Enjoy your 9.5, at most

I thought about putting...
"Brutally raping her with a chainsaw" but I figured that was just a little too much. :lol:bcrich959

Sorry to ask but how would one go about doing such... :P

[QUOTE="bcrich959"]I thought about putting...
"Brutally raping her with a chainsaw" but I figured that was just a little too much. :lol:Teh_Stevz

Sorry to ask but how would one go about doing such... :P

[QUOTE="Teh_Stevz"][QUOTE="bcrich959"]I thought about putting...
"Brutally raping her with a chainsaw" but I figured that was just a little too much. :lol:Jandurin

Sorry. I'm not much of a horror/thriller watcher. Would Saw or Final Destination(s) have any related scenes?