He made a lot of very good to great movies. I haven't followed him in the 2010s, except for Lincoln, which was alright. Saving Private Ryan is the most overrated of them all. The best thing I can say about it is that it brought us Band of Brothers.
Whenever I see someone saying Saving Private Ryan is meh or whatever, it always surprises me, and sure, it may look like it's overrated but for a good reason though.
For me, it's the best WW2 movie I've ever seen. While I imagine the real D-Day was very much more brutal its depiction in the film is at least the closest to it a movie has gotten and D-Day was the turning point in WW2. And for that, we had the men who were actually there saying that. At the time there were still a ton of WW2 vets alive. Most were in their 70s, and I remember a lot of the hype included vets who were really there saying it's the closest thing to what it really looked like. A lot of local news stories where some were being interviewed about it, about how some of them cried, etc. I remember thinking it felt very predatory and scummy on the part of the media but of course that's always been their m-o. Nothing wrong with Band of Brothers, just doesn't come close to what SPR did.
No, Band of Brothers is better, for not diving so much into melodrama and situations quite so contrived. Feels more real for it.
Another weak one that most people like is The Last Crusade. That one is worse than Saving Private Ryan, but it isn't as highly regarded. It's a dumber Indiana Jones with weaker setpieces and more embarrassing humor.
Log in to comment