GTHD looks better than PGR3

[QUOTE="-Sir-Poof-"]

[QUOTE="Felous1"]The car models look better. But PGR3 beats GT in the environment department.


http://youtube.com/watch?v=EjhhpcxrW6U
jack244

But whats more important?

Neither. There should be a good balance between textures, environments, cars.

I mean we might as well use PS1 environments so we can use every last bit of power on the cars so they are completley perfectly reproduced right? Wrong, because good looking models in a poor environment takes away from the graphics. What about FIght Night Round 3? Why not just have a ring with a black backround so we can get perfect photo-realistic boxers? Cause it the bigger picture of the game would look like crap.

Im trying to explain that if i had to choose which had better graphics between envirorments and car models i would choose car models thats all.

ok so GTHD looks better than PG3- Big Deal PS3 fans- ive got PGR3 & guess what? the game is old (released in Nov 05) the game was rushed out for launch- it wasnt rendered in 720p(it was upscaled to 720p) plus i t didnt have full anti-aliasing either which is why the jaggies on the car edges are VERY noticeable in PGR3. but here's the thing- if you view the races in Photo-mode you'll notice that the visuals are near-perfect- because anti-aliasing was incorporated into that mode.CwlHeddwyn

yeah cause its a tech demo of a game that got cancelled, we cant have fun till probably winter 08

ok so GTHD looks better than PG3- Big Deal PS3 fans- ive got PGR3 & guess what? the game is old (released in Nov 05) the game was rushed out for launch- it wasnt rendered in 720p(it was upscaled to 720p) plus i t didnt have full anti-aliasing either which is why the jaggies on the car edges are VERY noticeable in PGR3. but here's the thing- if you view the races in Photo-mode you'll notice that the visuals are near-perfect- because anti-aliasing was incorporated into that mode.CwlHeddwyn

Now was that so hard? I like ppl that can straight up tell their honest opinion rather than defend their system of choice.

I think we should wait until GT5 comes out to see if they can get that level of car detail on screen with alot more than 1 car. We'll see if the if the environment catches up to PGR 3.

We should also wait until PGR 4 so we can see what PGR looks like in at least true 720p with full AA. We'll see how the cars hold up to GTHD.

[QUOTE="danneswegman"][QUOTE="AgentVX"]

[QUOTE="danneswegman"]

denial the only game with better environments than PGR3 is crysisAgentVX

i don't have to deny.... i have a 360 and i love it.. pGR3 ia a jaggfest. the environments are okay, but look not as detailed as your sreens. Why defend that game? did you work on the environments personally. Don't try to convince me. like i said, i.ve played it an i played it on a HD projector on a 100 inch screen... guess you're the one in denial... show me these environments in GAMEPLAY...

There is your problem right their, 100 inch HD projector sucks for detail.  Play on a real HD TV and get back too me.

As I said, your problem is with you HD projector, it sucks for displaying detail, brightness and contrast.  I'm sure your happy with your projector and detail, but in terms of a gaming display, HD projectors are just for the "WOW, that's huge" factor, not, "WOW, that looks sooo goood!"

So again, when you get a real HD monitor and not HD projector to start judging how good graphics are, get back to us.  And LOL, please......it's way better than any HDTV that I seen, now that's a good one.....LOL.

why do cows never show pics of GTHD that have the environement/track visible? oh ya cuz it makes it look liek a PS2 gameXboxUnderground

I hate to tell you this, but it's not possible to make any game look more realistic than GT 5 HD on any console, period!

[QUOTE="XboxUnderground"]why do cows never show pics of GTHD that have the environement/track visible? oh ya cuz it makes it look liek a PS2 gamecasey7672

I hate to tell you this, but it's not possible to make any game look more realistic than GT 5 HD on any console, period!

the saddest part of this post is that he TRULY believes this b.s.... :lol:

atleast compare 2 games in the same genre. new forza screens at ign yesterday

OpticalCanine

GT HD's cars look better and thats all that matters because when your going 150 mph you dont have time to stare at your surroundings.Kahuna_1

GT is a very slow paced game, so you do take in your surroundings, which have poor graphics (from what I've heard and seen in videos GT:HD has poor environments). PGR3 moves much faster than GT, so you don't notice the surroundings, which means you have to look at the cars (which have poor graphics). PGR3 has poor car models but good environments, and GT:HD has good car models but poor environments

[QUOTE="Kahuna_1"]GT HD's cars look better and thats all that matters because when your going 150 mph you dont have time to stare at your surroundings.Mass_Effect

GT is a very slow paced game, so you do take in your surroundings, which have poor graphics (from what I've heard and seen in videos GT:HD has poor environments). PGR3 moves much faster than GT, so you don't notice the surroundings, which means you have to look at the cars (which have poor graphics). PGR3 has poor car models but good environments, and GT:HD has good car models but poor environments

So overall they are both just as good looking...but in different ways.

Like I said, the real comparison will be PGR 4 vs GT5. Not PGR 3 vs GTHD which is a rushed launch game vs a cancelled game turned 1 car on screen tech-demo.

[QUOTE="XboxUnderground"]why do cows never show pics of GTHD that have the environement/track visible? oh ya cuz it makes it look liek a PS2 gameHammerofjustice

No, its the handling of the cars that matters the most; not the graphics. GT has always had great graphics, but unfortunately is too slow paced and boring

[QUOTE="Hammerofjustice"][QUOTE="XboxUnderground"]why do cows never show pics of GTHD that have the environement/track visible? oh ya cuz it makes it look liek a PS2 gameMass_Effect

No, its the handling of the cars that matters the most; not the graphics. GT has always had great graphics, but unfortunately is too slow paced and boring

There I said it,I'm tired of lemming claiming PGR3 is the best looknig racer out there.Its not
Take a look at the cars.

gsx1100

I'm a 360 owner and shall say some good things about the GT series. I remember playing GT3 and really enjoyed how you could buy parts for your car, to me this was a very cool feature that I wish was in more games (at leas the way it was done in GT3). Second, is that out of all the racing games out there only GT4 has been favorite car, the Delorean DMC-12, I wish more games had it. jd7-03

I love the customization in GT games, and the vast amount of cars you can get, but thats all really. GT beat Forza hands down in terms of (the amount of) cars, but forza had much more realistic handling and was just better overrall in the gameplay department.

PGR3: VERY, VERY good (just shy of excellent) car models
Grive

Honestly, how can you say that? The cars looked really bad in PGR3.

[QUOTE="Grive"] PGR3: VERY, VERY good (just shy of excellent) car models
Mass_Effect

Honestly, how can you say that? The cars looked really bad in PGR3.

Bad? 360 owner or not that is complete BS. PGR 3 has the second best car models in any game ever made (the best when it first came out) next to GTHD and you say they look bad?

[QUOTE="Mass_Effect"]

[QUOTE="Grive"] PGR3: VERY, VERY good (just shy of excellent) car models
jack244

Honestly, how can you say that? The cars looked really bad in PGR3.

Bad? 360 owner or not that is complete BS. PGR 3 has the second best car models in any game ever made (the best when it first came out) next to GTHD and you say they look bad?

Have you played the game? The cars look bland and are full of "jaggies". Some cars look good (like the F50), but the majority look poor.

[QUOTE="jack244"][QUOTE="Mass_Effect"]

[QUOTE="Grive"] PGR3: VERY, VERY good (just shy of excellent) car models
Mass_Effect

Honestly, how can you say that? The cars looked really bad in PGR3.

Bad? 360 owner or not that is complete BS. PGR 3 has the second best car models in any game ever made (the best when it first came out) next to GTHD and you say they look bad?

Have you played the game? The cars look bland and are full of "jaggies". Some cars look good (like the F50), but the majority look poor.

Also if you say PGR 3 cars look bad, please feel free to post pics of another game OTHER than GTHD that has better cars.

Honestly, how can you say that? The cars looked really bad in PGR3.

Mass_Effect

Have you played the game? The cars look bland and are full of "jaggies". Some cars look good (like the F50), but the majority look poor.

[QUOTE="Mass_Effect"]

Honestly, how can you say that? The cars looked really bad in PGR3.

Grive

Have you played the game? The cars look bland and are full of "jaggies". Some cars look good (like the F50), but the majority look poor.

Mass_Effect

I also own PGR 3 and I agree. For any doubters my gamertag is Jack244, check my game list.

There I said it,I'm tired of lemming claiming PGR3 is the best looknig racer out there.Its not
Take a look at the cars.

PGR3


GTHD

PGR3 looks good but GT looks way better.






gsx1100

[QUOTE="gsx1100"]There I said it,I'm tired of lemming claiming PGR3 is the best looknig racer out there.Its not
Take a look at the cars.

PGR3


GTHD

PGR3 looks good but GT looks way better.






Danthegamingman

[QUOTE="gsx1100"]There I said it,I'm tired of lemming claiming PGR3 is the best looknig racer out there.Its not
Take a look at the cars.

PGR3


GTHD

PGR3 looks good but GT looks way better.






Danthegamingman

photobucket.com

[QUOTE="Danthegamingman"][QUOTE="gsx1100"]There I said it,I'm tired of lemming claiming PGR3 is the best looknig racer out there.Its not
Take a look at the cars.

PGR3


GTHD

PGR3 looks good but GT looks way better.






BioShockOwnz

pasted mountains?

[QUOTE="ironwarrior2"]PGR3 isn't even in 720p, it's sub-hd. MoterStorm is a beautiful game.XboxUnderground

Almost meaning GT HD owned  it Hard

[QUOTE="gsx1100"]There I said it,I'm tired of lemming claiming PGR3 is the best looknig racer out there.Its not
Take a look at the cars.

PGR3


GTHD

PGR3 looks good but GT looks way better.






Danthegamingman

More like a Demo >> Full game = TLHBO

AT is it TRue PGR3 =/= 720P and runs at like 30 FPS?????

photobucket.com

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"][QUOTE="Danthegamingman"][QUOTE="gsx1100"]There I said it,I'm tired of lemming claiming PGR3 is the best looknig racer out there.Its not
Take a look at the cars.

PGR3


GTHD

PGR3 looks good but GT looks way better.






SupraGT

pasted mountains?

That is a real-life photograph pasted on to a very low poly mesh. It looks awful. Here are some PGR3 enviroments to feast your eyes on.

[QUOTE="Mass_Effect"]

[QUOTE="Hammerofjustice"][QUOTE="XboxUnderground"]why do cows never show pics of GTHD that have the environement/track visible? oh ya cuz it makes it look liek a PS2 gamejd7-03

No, its the handling of the cars that matters the most; not the graphics. GT has always had great graphics, but unfortunately is too slow paced and boring

There I said it,I'm tired of lemming claiming PGR3 is the best looknig racer out there.Its not
Take a look at the cars.

PGR3


GTHD

PGR3 looks good but GT looks way better.






gsx1100

Ok...Let's say you are completely correct in your graphical assessment....then :lol: @ the fact that it is taking this long for PS3 to even match the graphics of a 360 launch title :lol:

Is PS3 that pathetic?